Mathew W. McCallister v. State of Indiana

── Mathew W. McCallister v. State of Indiana ── Case No.: 24A-PC-01521 Court: Indiana Court of Appeals Date: September 26, 2025 Author: Judge Paul Felix County of Origin: Warrick Category: Criminal Decision: Affirmed Judge Pyle and Judge Weissmann concur In 2016, a jury convicted McCallister of murder and conspiracy to commit murder as a Class A felony. The Indiana Supreme Court has previously set out the facts underlying those convictions: During February 2014, Defendant, Mathew McCallister, lived with his girlfriend, Kelli Wyrick, in a series of hotels in Evansville, Indiana. Also living in Evansville hotels then were their friends Shawn Grigsby and Grigsby’s girlfriend. The two couples would sometimes visit each other’s rooms to use illegal drugs.