All StatesIndianaElizabeth Tavitas › Evidence
Neutral Court Opinion Mar 01, 2026

Matthew Lucious Setlak v. State of Indiana

── Matthew Lucious Setlak v. State of Indiana ── Case No.: 23A-CR-02516 Court: Indiana Court of Appeals Date: April 26, 2024 Author: Judge Elizabeth Tavitas County of Origin: Lake Category: Criminal Decision: Affirmed Judge Mathias and Judge Weissmann concur The victim, L.B., was born in April 2015. Thirty-five-year-old Setlak was a friend of L.B.’s parents and was L.B.’s godfather. L.B. referred to Setlak as “Uncle Matt.” Tr. Vol. II p. 7. In 2017, Setlak regularly babysat L.B. and her brother. The children often spent the night with Setlak, who would feed and bathe the children. [4] In the fall of 2017, L.B.’s mother (“Mother”) was changing two-year-old L.B.’s diaper when she noticed that L.B.’s anal and vaginal areas were red and that there was a discharge coming from the child’s vagina.
Indiana Judicial Branch
https://public.courts.in.gov/Decisions/api/Document/Opinion?Id=DrtUkctEPeA7K0wS…
Elizabeth Tavitas Indiana Court of Appeals Judge Peter Foley Indiana Court of Appeals Judge
Share on X Share on Facebook
← Back to Elizabeth Tavitas's profile