Kosher Eats v. Welch

── Kosher Eats v. Welch ── Court: Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit Date: April 13, 2026 Category: General Appellate Case: 25-4062 Document: 55-1 Date Filed: 04/13/2026 Page: 1 FILED United States Court of Appeals UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS Tenth Circuit FOR THE TENTH CIRCUIT April 13, 2026 _________________________________ Christopher M. Wolpert Clerk of Court KOSHER EATS LLC, a Florida limited liability company; EMERALD CONSULTING PARTNERS LLC, a Florida limited liability company; ABBSON LLC, a New York limited liability company; MSC COMPANIES, LLC, a Utah limited liability company; HOMEPEOPLE CORPORATION, a New York corporation, Plaintiffs - Appellants, v. No. 25-4062 (D.C. No. 2:24-CV-00520-DBB) TORBEN WELCH, an individual; (D. Utah) CALEB MEYER, an individual; MICHELLE HARDEN, an individual; RENNE FINCH, an individual; DAVID REEVES, an individual; BENJAMIN TIETGEN, an individual; DARREN ALBERTI, an individual; KATE BAILEY, an individual; BRENDA BARTELS, an individual; ALEX BELTZ, an individual; AMBER BLASINGAME, an individual; BRETT BOON, an individual; VALERIE BROMLEY, an individual; EDGAR CARRANZA, an individual; KATHLEEN CARTER, an individual; CYNTHIA CARUCCI, an individual; CHARLES CAVANAGH, an individual; LAURA CHARTRAND, an individual; GREGORY COHEN, an individual; KIMBERLEY CRONIN, an individual; ISAAC CRUM; ERICA DEATHERAGE, an individual; MATTHEW DEENIHAN, an individual; ALLISON DODD, an individual; BRIEANNA DOLMAGE, an individual; PATRICK DRAKE, an individual; R.J.  Appellate Case: 25-4062 Document: 55-1 Date Filed: 04/13/2026 Page: 2 ERTMER; RACHEL FARR, an individual; MARY BRYNE FLETCHER, an individual; AUSTIN GEMMELL, an individual; MATTHEW GEORGE, an individual; DEANNA GILBERTSON, an individual; MARGARET GRAY; SCOTT HAWRANEK, an individual; ANDREW HOLLINS, an individual; AMY HUFF, an individual; CRAIG HUMPHREY, an individual; MATT JEDRZEJEK, an individual; MACLAIN JOYCE, an individual; IDIN KASHEFIPOUR, an individual; DARA KELLER, an individual; DANIEL KLETT, an individual; STEVEN KNAUSS, an individual; MARJORIE KRATSAS, an individual; JASON MARTINEZ, an individual; BRYANT MESSNER, an individual; IAN MITCHELL, an individual; SCOTT MONROE, an individual; SIMONE MONTOYA, an individual; BRUCE MONTOYA, an individual; KATHLEEN MOWRY, an individual; CHRISTINA MUNDY, an individual; ANN NGUYEN, an individual; KATHERINE OTTO, an individual; JONATHAN OWENS, an individual; JULIAN PARDO DE ZELA, an individual; FRANK PERRETTA, an individual; PETER PIERCE, an individual; WILLIAM RANDALL, an individual; RICHARD REICE, an individual; ADAM ROYVAL, an individual; HEATHER SALG, an individual; EDWIN SCHWARTZ, an individual; MIKHAIL SHAH, an individual; GREG SITRICK, an individual; ROWAN SMITH, an individual; AARON SOLEIMANI; HEATHER STERN, an individual; JOHN STEVENS, an individual; DEANNE STODDEN, an individual; MATTHEW SULLIVAN, an individual; JENNY THORNTON, an individual; WADE WARTHEN, an individual; ANDREW 2  Appellate Case: 25-4062 Document: 55-1 Date Filed: 04/13/2026 Page: 3 WELCH; KARIE WILSON, an individual; DOUGLAS WOLANSKE, an individual; JON ZIMMERMAN, an individual; JAKE BRIGHAM, an individual; MESSNER REEVES LLP, a Colorado partnership; MESSNER GENERAL PARTNERSHIP, Defendants - Appellees. _________________________________ ORDER AND JUDGMENT * _______________________________