Nicole Kemp v. Bay Horse Inn, LLC, et al.

── Nicole Kemp v. Bay Horse Inn, LLC, et al. ── Case No.: 24A-SC-01298 Court: Indiana Court of Appeals Date: January 14, 2025 Author: Judge Robert Altice County of Origin: Johnson Category: Civil Decision: Reversed Judge Vaidik and Judge Crone concur Case Summary In a private Facebook group called Indiana Dynamic Women of Johnson County (the Group), Nicole Kemp made an anonymous post about Amanda Johnson, owner of Bay Horse Inn, LLC (BHI), an event center in Greenwood that hosts weddings, fundraisers, and other events. Kemp’s post urged members of the Group to boycott BHI, giving several reasons why she believed Johnson did not “stand with” the liberal values of the Group.